Argentina: Trade Restrictions and Policy Uncertainties

Argentina

The recent imposition of additional trade restrictions coupled with economic policy uncertainties in Argentina continue to cast doubt onto the country’s economic outlook for 2012. Our clients and experts expect operational conditions to further deteriorate as surging government spending and minimal political opposition allows President Kirchner’s administration to continue on this volatile path. This volatility is leading many MNC executives to adopt a “wait-and-see” approach when conducting operations in Argentina. Indeed, 57% of FSG advisors reported being concerned about economic stability in Argentina, while 59% of clients believe in a likely economic crisis within the next 18 months.

Argentina’s troubles stem from high government spending, which has eliminated previous years of budget surplus while pushing upwards pressure on inflation. An appreciating peso has been boosting imports at the expense of the trade balance and further contributing to the budget deficit. The increase in non-automatic import licenses and the Argentine government’s demand for import pre-approvals has further complicated multinational operations in an already challenging economic environment. Judging by the positive Argentine public response to the nationalization of YPF it is hard to expect the Argentina government will adjust its restrictive course and instead apply economic austerity programs.

Despite increased restrictions, import strategies like engaging in government relationship building or increasing local production can potentially reward companies willing to take the risks. Finding locally produced products to export (or countertrading) can help companies come in line with Argentine government demands.

There are two likely scenarios to consider over the next 18 months: economic crisis or economic rebalancing. Under a worst-case scenario, Argentina will continue to muddle through with the current policies it has in place until the economic imbalances worsen to the point where a crisis ensues. A more positive scenario envisions Argentina enacting politically difficult austerity and a gradual devaluation of the peso that would set the economy on track for long-term economic growth and stability. At this point it is difficult to say which of these scenarios will likely prevail, but the fact that improvement will require Argentina to endure near term pain to achieve long-term gain does not bode well for multinationals.

*Erick Soto contributed to this piece

Latin America - Emerging Markets Insights - June 2012


LATAM

Multinationals are taking note of the strength of the Andean economies of Colombia and Peru, but the increasingly negative outlook in Argentina and Brazil is weighing down growth in the region. Stagnating industrial output and diminishing consumer demand in Brazil led economists to trim economic growth expectations to less than 3% for 2012. The race for the Mexican presidency heats up as PRI candidate Enrique Peña Nieto maintains a steady lead heading into the July election. Meanwhile, the race for Venezuela’s presidency in October is underway contributing to market uncertainty as president Chavez registers to run for a third term despite his poor health.

For a more detailed insight on key trends in Latin America, here are the analyst headlines for our key markets:

  • Argentina:A thriving black market for dollars and widespread withdrawals from local banks signal a growing belief that boom times are over
  • Brazil: Multinationals are facing increasing headwinds as the effectiveness of government stimulus falls short of expectations and credit markets soften
  • Chile: Higher-than-expected export growth is keeping Chile’s economy buoyant, but protests continue to mar President Piñera’s government
  • Colombia:Colombia’s potential is no longer a secret, but popularity brings a pricey peso that is eroding competitiveness
  • Mexico: Multinationals look to Mexico as a safe haven to weather the European storm
  • Peru: Stellar performance is only somewhat dimmed by concern over tax reform increasing the cost of doing business in Peru
  • Venezuela: Oil-fueled spending is succeeding at supporting higher growth this year, but Chavez’s poor health is creating political uncertainty

*Erick Soto contributed to this piece.

May 2012 Latin America Outlook: Taking Global Volatility In Stride

Frontier Strategy Group’s clients are revising growth forecasts for Latin America’s major economies upwards as the outlook for the global economy begins to stabilize. Growth leaders are emerging in the Andean region, and we expect that Chile, Colombia, and Peru will contend for the highest growth rate in Latin America in 2012. Strong fundamentals are keeping the Mexican economy remarkably stable while Brazil continues to miss the mark. Finally Argentina and Venezuela’s risk profile is increasing significantly, forcing MNCs to reconsider whether the potential rewards warrant the blood, sweat, and tears.

For a more detailed insight on key trends in Latin America, here are the analyst headlines for our key markets:

  • Argentina: The nationalization of YPF has become the clearest indication of the Fernandez Administration’s hostility to investor concerns
  • Brazil: The Brazilian government remains committed to revitalizing the economy, but it has not yet had a discernible impact on industry
  • Chile: Strengthening domestic demand, higher copper prices and an improving international outlook point to continued strength for Chile’s economy
  • Colombia: Strong growth in an uncertain global environment is forcing Colombia to deal with an appreciating currency and rising wages
  • Mexico: Economic prospects appear to be stabilizing, but drug war violence sustains tension
  • Peru: Growing pains in spite of robust consumer spending
  • Venezuela: Chávez looks to foreign patronage to offset the deleterious effects of economic domination by decree

*Melissa Pegus, Senior Analyst - Latin America contributed to this piece

Brazil’s Government Bets on Decreasing Inflation

Trend

Recent policy choices indicate that political considerations are being placed ahead of sound economic management

The central bank’s decision to cut interest rates, despite high inflation and employment, and subsequent intervention to arrest the depreciation of the real has created a tremendous amount of volatility

Industrial policy has become paramount as protectionism leaps into the fore, jeopardizing long-term competitiveness

Import taxes and foreign ownership laws are worsening regulatory uncertainty, leading some companies to rethink investment decisions

By choosing to shelter local producers rather than cut red tape and invest in infrastructure and human capital, the government is further distorting market incentives

Drivers

The government is betting that inflation will decrease as the global economy cools, making growth a higher priority

Financial markets are pricing in an additional 100 basis points worth of cuts to the SELIC rate by the end of the year

Political pressure to address the currency has been building ever since the Dilma administration took office

Dilma is hemmed in by a governing coalition and constitution that makes it difficult to enact long-term reforms to boost competitiveness

Frontier Strategy Group View

The recent spate of pro-inflationary policies poses serious risks to the Brazilian economy, especially given recent demands by workers to raise wages in 2012. If the global economy fails to deteriorate as much as Brazilian officials are expecting, a scenario that is not currently FSG’s base case, inflation could become a major problem

B2C companies selling to low and lower-middle income consumer segments should be wary as inflation reduces the purchasing power of these demographics the most

 

5 Risks to India’s Growth in Q4 2011

While the impact of Western volatility on Asian markets is cause for concern, this is just one force buffeting the Indian economy. Other risks to watch in Q4 and first half of 2012 are currency volatility, inflation, policy paralysis and farm output:

1) Western Recession

  • While India’s exports have withstood the global gloom so far, prolonged insecurity in Western markets could have a large impact on exports

2) Currency Volatility

  • The weak rupee may provide a short-term boost to exporters, but uncertainty around currency volatility will negate the benefits

3) Inflation

  • Inflation remains a consistent threat to business input costs, wage levels, and household consumption, as FSG observed in Q3

4) Policy Paralysis

  • This summer’s scandals halted business as usual in Parliament, and may continue to stall crucial policymaking on social and business issues

5) Poor Farm Output

  • Agriculture accounts for 17% of GDP and employs over 50% of the populace. A weak monsoon will hurt rural markets and heighten inflation